Some
strange doings in my head this morning. Stranger than usual
anyway.
While shoveling new snow so MoSup can go to Mass, I thought of Kurt
Vonnegut. Out of the blue.
I loved the movie adapted from his Slaughterhouse
Five, but it was Harrison Bergeron
that cemented the idea into my head that Vonnegut was a visionary;
someone who could recognize and extrapolate consequences from
emerging
tyrannies. I was quite jolted then by his
celebrated-by-the-left quote ..
"The only difference between Hitler and Bush
is that Hitler was elected."
And another celebrated
by the left quote
"Our
president is a Christian? So was Adolf Hitler."
If Vonnegut was who I thought he was, it meant that I was wrong. Despite
all evidence to the contrary, Al Gore was the rightful 43rd President
of the United States. Bush was the liar; not Gore. Bush and Hitler were good Christians and bad men. If
a Bush agent hadn't killed him by pushing him down the stairs in 2007,
what would he be writing today about Obamunism? Could he, would
he, overcome his
biases and see the truth of Obama? I suspect not, or not until
events made it inescapable, and then who would care?
The year was 2081, and everybody was
finally equal. They weren't only
equal before God and the law. They were equal every which way. Nobody
was smarter than anybody else. Nobody was better looking than anybody
else. Nobody was stronger or quicker than anybody else. All this
equality was due to the 211th, 212th, and 213th Amendments to the
Constitution, and to the unceasing vigilance of agents of the United
States Handicapper General.
—From " Harrison Bergeron " (1961), a
short story by Kurt Vonnegut
What of George
Orwell? He wrote of his participation in the
Spanish civil war, "I have seen wonderful things and at last
really believe in Socialism, which I never did before." Then
he wrote Animal
Farm. and
Nineteen Eighty-Four. It's
true that he hated Stalin, but died believing still in the promise of The State.
What novel would he write about
Obamunism? Or was that novel Animal Farm II?
I was well into writing this when I discovered that Bret Stephens (Kurt
Vonnegut's State of the Union) was channeling me in an article Updating
a story about government-mandated absolute equality. Will
Hollywood make this movie?
|
Then they had to execute them all because they were all equally guilty of murder.
ReplyDeleteignore amos
Well, here's ONE version (I liked it):
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmEOI5zwFMM&list=PL7E455A7EB1217E29
Thanks Kauffer - Try the Hot Link example and and become an even better commenter.
ReplyDeleteI read a lot of Vonnegut in my early 20s, in fact, I believe that I read everything he had written. I quit when I realized about a quarter of the way through "the new book," Hocus Pocus, that I was sympathizing with a cold-blooded killer.
ReplyDeleteThe biggest problem I have with Vonnegut is that he tries to battle an injustice by creating a world that is consumed by that injustice. His primarily college student audience will then substitute his writing for real-world experience and grow to believe that the world is as he says it is.
Hitler was never elected in Germany. He was the leader of his party, the National Socialist Party, and appointed Chancellor by Hindenberg.
ReplyDelete