Friday, December 18, 2009

AP Bolsheviks

AP: Authoritarian Propaganda
The wire service "reports" that skepticism is the bane of science.


Curmudgeonly & Skeptical

 See if you can guess the source of this quote:
Once, not so long ago, the planet's prevailing voices were those of the experts--the people who, right or wrong, had years of training to back up what they said. Then came the Internet, and everything changed.
Wrong.  It was the same guy who just wrote this ...
Consider the global warming debate: The skeptics shout. The skeptics' opponents shout back. The scientists insist they have research in their corner. And public debate shifts from the provable and the empirical toward the spectacle of argument.
Democracy in action? That's one way of seeing it. But is something deeper afoot? As the amplification of human opinion becomes more democratic, is the suspicion of the expert and the intellectual--a long-held trope in American society--going globally viral?
[Cont]

8 comments:

Spunky Texan said...

Even though they coronated the 0ne it is still crumbling around them.

Anonymous said...

Everyone knows the first half of this Buckley quote, but it's the second half that packs the wallop:

I'd rather be governed by the first two-thousand names in the Boston telephone directory, than the faculty of Harvard, because given the opportunity, the faculty of Harvard would vote for Utopia, and the search for Utopia in the 20th century lead us from the gulag to the death camps.

Apologies to WFB, but I can no longer find the full quote after a fifteen minute search. The intertubes are all clogged up with Daily Kos shit.

Casca

TimO said...

How quickly everyone forgets: In 1902, the scientific consensus was that man could not, and never would, fly.....

Consensus is NOT science.

rockville said...

It's not that we've become more skeptical and suspicious. That really hasn't changed.

What has changed is the ability to fact-check the "experts", making it harder for them to fool us.

Consequently, our trust of the media has evaporated. That, too, has changed.

Anonymous said...

"The scientists insist they have research in their corner. "
insisting ≠ proving / demonstrating / showing evidence

This'd be a swell argument, IF the *cough* experts' arguments were more factual and less pejorative. What this elite-wannabe mistakes for suspicion of the Innn-te-leck-chew-all is merely an everyday demonstration of the adage, "you can't fool all of the people all of the time."

Part of that ol' 'American exceptionalism,' really; believing in the ability of the 'common man' to spot bullshit and avoid stepping in it.

Not really a skill set of the elite intellectual, though...

e~C

Anonymous said...

Ok. I admit to idiocy.


WHY!!!! is Algore given such credence. Every time I turn around I discover another 'discrepancy' {can you hear it in his voice - Dis Crep An Cee} in what he is blathering about and NO ONE calls him on it.
Not even Tommy Lee ...


tom

BlogDog said...

Casca,
See the fourth item at the Buckley Wikiquote.

Rodger the Real King of France said...

e~C - see me after class (key under the mat).

Post a Comment

Just type your name and post as anonymous if you don't have a Blogger profile.