Monday, July 26, 2010

Making numbers dance

Numbers Schmumbers


Boned Jello

The NY Times Saturday compared the cost of America's wars, and concluded the combined Iraq/Afghanistan campaigns against fascist Islam are the second most expensive in history.  Daniel Halper (Weekly Standard) puts things in perspective.
But the real story is in the chart, not the accompanying article. The actual cost of the war in Afghanistan and Iraq is extraordinarily low, when seen as a percentage of GDP. Whereas World War II constituted 35.8 percent of GDP spending, and whereas World War I made up 13.6 percent of GDP spending, the current wars in Afghanistan and Iraq (or what the Times calls "Afghanistan/Iraq/post-9/11) made up only 1.2 percent of GDP in 2008. The chart helpfully compares this to other wars: It falls in between the Mexican War (1847) and the Spanish-American War (1899).

Now, in these comparative terms, it seems that spending for these wars is not nearly high enough, considering the enormous consequences of defeat in either Iraq or Afghanistan.

5 comments:

Jess said...

I'm thinking the White House vacations are right up there with the Spanish American War. After Michelle's European venture, they may be up there with Vietnam, or Korea.

Anonymous said...

Good observation Jess. And Uhbama's travel and party costs are probably right up there with Social Security.
Lt. Col. Gen. Tailgunner dick

TimO said...

That also doesn't take into account the $2billion (1940 dollars) they spend to develop the A-Bomb.

That REALLY would pop that chart up....

DougM said...

I wonder how the cost of the NYT stacks up.

It's startin' to look just like one of those commie rags you see in corner dispensers.

TheOldMan said...

The Iraq, Afghanistan, etc... operations would be much less expensive and more successful if we ran them in the same way as WWII (after we got our act together, 1943 onward). Flatten, demand unconditional surrender, flatten some more, demand, flatten, ok we got it. Today's problem is that there is no one answer the demand although we could come up with a top 100 list.

Post a Comment

Just type your name and post as anonymous if you don't have a Blogger profile.