Friday, December 10, 2010

Jelly Roll Michelle

The Delusional Donut
The Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act has passed the House of Representatives and will soon be signed into law by President Obama. Indeed, first lady Michelle Obama has touted the legislation as the centerpiece of her efforts to combat childhood obesity in the United States.

Hunger-Free Act


We doubt the legislation will do much to improve childhood nutrition, and its economics are suspect.

•Schools already lose money on each meal they serve. Compliance with stricter federal nutrition guidelines will increase costs for schools that want to qualify for the increased reimbursements, offsetting some or all of that extra six cents per meal. That could well mean a greater burden on local budgets, not a lesser one.

•Banning so-called empty calories won’t force children to eat broccoli. It will cause some to simply bring their favorite foods to school, skipping what’s on offer in the cafeteria, resulting in greater waste and no better nutrition.

•Junk food has a role in obesity and poor health, but decisions to ban it should be made at the district level. This legislation expands government in an area where it has no constitutional role. We’re confident James and Dolley Madison never envisioned Congress barring schoolchildren from consuming cupcakes.

The most egregious aspect of the legislation is its financing ... .  [US policy in schools distasteful continued]



10 comments:

toadold said...

Over a decade ago a German scientist investigated why on the average Americans were fatter than Europeans. His conclusion was it was not the food so much as it was that most of American citites and towns were designed after the invention of the automobile. In Europe the towns and cities preceded that and due to narrow streets and passage ways people had to walk more. They also had more stairs to climb. The smaller living spaces also led to smaller food storage areas so people made more walking trips to get food.
Despite that the Europeans are getting fatter. If I remember correctly the telling quote is, "If you unrolled the average toilet paper roll and used it to represent the history of the human race, one sheet would represent the period where there was enough food to make obesity a problem. We are not evolved for this abundance.

Anonymous said...

I blame it on the spread of Costco.

Casca

Anonymous said...

Rog is right, it's the Crispy Cremes.

Anonymous said...

Look how those donuts make her ankles look puffy.

Anonymous said...

Why do schools provide lunches in the first place? I spent the first 8 of my school years in a Catholic school to which all the pupils brought their lunches from home. The student body was 100% working class with many of us from families that would be considered impoverished by today's standards, but I never once saw anyone go hungry.
The parents have the obligation to feed their children,not the public. All of this nanny state crap just fosters irresponsibility

Cheesy said...

40 years ago my Grandfather was head of maintenance at the local elementary school.
I don't know how much subsidy went into student lunches then, but the amount of wasted food was staggering. Grandpa would have the students sort food from trash into barrels and that went a long way in feeding the hogs he raised on his mini-farm.
Do we want to know how much of the food our tax dollars pay for is wasted nowadays?

Anonymous said...

Many years ago when my kids were in Socialist WV public schools - they weren't allowed to ask cafeteria workers to not put food they weren't going to eat on their tray.

The workers were required by state law to put all the gross veggies and crap that no kid likes on their plates knowing full well it was headed to the trash.

Just one of many reasons we got the hell out of that state,

TFV

Anonymous said...

A friend of mine worked at a convenience store back in the day. He was rightfully p'd off at a woman who would walk her two kids to school every morning for the free breakfast and then on the way home would stop and buy a quart of malt liquor and two scratch off lottery tickets.

Yep, uh-huh...hmmm...

Hairy Nosed Wombat.

Anonymous said...

What's the deal with that right foot?

Rodger the Real King of France said...

prolly diabetic amputation

Post a Comment

Just type your name and post as anonymous if you don't have a Blogger profile.