Monday, March 06, 2006

Turning in tax cheats

Ethics
I am surprised to learn that 62% of Americans now say they would turn in a neighbor who was a tax cheat, up from 53% last year.  That, according to a poll by the IRS oversight committee, or some such.  More surprising is my reaction.  At first blush I said ''never.''  But, E.D. Hill's question to Brian Kilmeade, the Fox Friend who said the same thing was, ''does that mean you wouldn't turn in people committing other crimes?''

That's the dilemma, but she's right.  Upon further reflection, it's not the IRS I hate, it's our lawmakers who created that agency who are to blame, and the answer is political.  If
we really wanted it - and I do mean really, because Congress loves the power the current tax code gives them, and will resist mightily, but we could force reform along the line of a flat-tax.  That can never happen now, because we do not even listen to the same debate any longer.  Still,  I was taught not to snitch, so I would not. Unless I didn't like the neighbor.

My head hurts.

One more thing.  During the discussion someone asked if there was a reward, and the answer was no. Wrong.  People who turn in tax cheats are given a percentage of recovered money.  Now, that's really insidious. Here's my own Poll, and you can't quibble the way I did.

Would you turn in a tax cheat neighbor?
Yes
No
  
Free polls from Pollhost.com

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Anybody that can find a way to keep a little of their money out of the hands of those filthy lieing fatassed thieving scumbags should get a medal.

Anonymous said...

What he said.

wmprof

Anonymous said...

Judging from the resultz so far, it looks like we're more anti-goverment extorting than neighbor snitching. joyce

Anonymous said...

Question 1: Have the results of that poll been verified? Cuz it sounds more like a public opinion shaper than a public opinion tester...

Question 2: Next -- turning in your neighbor for Thought Crimes.

*builds better fence around ranch*

Jake said...

I would use the Al Capone test to determine if I were going to turn in my neighbor for cheating. He would have to be guilty of some other crime before I would turn him in.

Such crimes as making too much noise late at night or letting their dog poop on my lawn would meet my Al Capone test.

Rodger the Real King of France said...

Claire , it was conducted by

http://www.treas.gov/irsob/index.html -

aka, the Gummint

AnnoyedOne said...

This isn't an ethical question for me. Why should I report someone for keeping their own money which the Dept. Of Legalized Theft, I mean IRS, confiscates under the threat of prison?

Rodger the Real King of France said...

Like I said, this is a sticky issue for me too, but ultimately it boils down to this question: ''Do you maintain the right to choose which laws to recognize?" '' Or, can you have yor cake and eat it too?

Anonymous said...

Well, if my neighbor was an outspoken liberal who constantly bitched about how the rich aren't paying their "fair" share, and agitates for higher taxes to support more "investment" in health, education and welfare, well, umm, yeah, I'd turn in his hypocritical ass in a heartbeat.

Post a Comment

Just type your name and post as anonymous if you don't have a Blogger profile.