Tuesday, March 30, 2010

The Howard Zinn factor

Glenn Beck:
Despite What You Might Think,
Nazis Were Not Right-Wing


Boned Jello

Duh.  I could go on for hours on this, and  have over the years. Suffice it to say that Beck is right; both Hitler and Stalin were socialists.  The major difference being that Hitler used the state's authority to direct what the private sector produced, while Stalin confiscated and ran the means of production.  Here's some of the comments to this New York Magazine article..
This is a ridiculous attempts at cheaply revising history.
Hitler was attacking big business and high finance? What about all the wealthy industrials who profited from Hitler's war-machine and from the concentration camps industry?
Hitler was expanding access to education? Or was it access to propaganda?
No wonder this Goldberg was on Fox News. Such cheap arguments are juicy material for easy explotation by Fox's neoliberal (neo liberal?) idiocratic agenda.
Let me set the record straight.
This is revisionism of the cheapest sort.

  By Alek2010 on 03/30/2010 at 5:18am


Glen Beck is an idiot. A major reason why people followed Hitler and the National Socialists was because of their fear of the Communists.

The Nazis wanted to return to a day when their nation was pure, before the immigrants moved in, before homosexuals came out, to stop the long haired swing kids, their era of hippie, to cut the national debt, to have a strong military and to re-arm the Rhineland, to cut down on crime done by immigrants, to end the power of the Jewish bankers, to cut the liberal Jewish owned media.

Sounds a lot like today's modern Tea Party.

  By redlands123 on 03/30/2010 at 7:58am


The right-wing in the U.S. decries attempts to rewrite history while rewriting history. Constantly. It's been a very effective strategy for them. Seemingly.

  By christopher1974 on 03/30/2010 at 8:08am


The sad thing is that the Texas School boards buy so many school textbooks that they can re-write history. Any wonder why some people actually will believe Glenn Beck? blah-blah-blah

There you have it, the root of our national problem.  Minds tampered with by leftist  education cadre.  Hell, even Naomi Wolf Thinks the Tea Parties Help Fight Fascism !

3 comments:

OregonGuy said...

What the hell do these people think the "socialist" in National Socialist meant?

That they liked to hold "socials"? Fry up some chicken and head to church, and don't forget the potato salad?

It's like listening to them talking about global warming, having watched the prize winning "An Inconvenient Truth." They don't even realize the errors when they come face to face with them. They aren't asked to question, they're asked to believe.

And bless their little hearts, they real good at it.
.

DougM said...

This is a major point of Jonah Goldberg's "Liberal Fascism" (a most excellent must-read, IMHO). Basically, it's current usage is based on the Stalinist application: you know, Right-Wing is anything not sufficiently Left-Wing Stalinist, including Trotskyites and pussy-commies.

Anonymous said...

I read a long time ago that Stalin launched the "Nazism is right wing" meme after WW2, to help distance himself from his pre-war schmoozing with Hitler. He also kept secret from his peoples the fact that before the war, Germany and the USSR had a mutual non-aggression pact.

Post a Comment

Just type your name and post as anonymous if you don't have a Blogger profile.