Comparing House, Senate versions
Sources: Associated Press and USA TODAY research
|
scream-of-consciousness; "If you're trying to change minds and influence people it's probably not a good idea to say that virtually all elected Democrats are liars, but what the hell."
Saturday, May 27, 2006
Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2006
"If the number of Islamic terror attacks continues at the current rate, candlelight vigils will soon be the number-one cause of global warming. " |
8 comments:
- Rodger the Real King of France said...
-
Illegals here 5 years are eligible for amnesty. How will we determine how long an illegal has been here? INS agents are required to take the sublect's word for it.
*******************************
. - 5/26/06, 8:50 AM
- Rodger the Real King of France said...
-
Howard the Oraculator has updated numbers.
103 MILLION, THANKS GEORGE
************************************************ - 5/26/06, 9:02 AM
-
-
“Top Ten Reasons to Oppose the Senate Amnesty Bill”
May 25th, 2006 - Washington D.C. - Today, Senator Jim DeMint (R-S.C) announced his intention to vote against the Senate immigration compromise that would grant amnesty to millions of illegal immigrants. Senator DeMint also released his “Top Ten Reasons to Oppose the Senate Amnesty Bill”.
“We will never solve the problem of illegal immigration by rewarding those who break our laws,” said Senator DeMint. “We must stop illegal immigration by securing the border and creating a temporary worker program that does not reward illegal behavior with a clear path to citizenship and voting rights.”
“This bill fails to do that. Instead, it guarantees amnesty with only the promise of border security and enforcement. We tried the same formula in 1986, and it only made the problem worse. This puts those here illegally in front of those waiting to enter the right way, and that’s the wrong message for a nation of laws to send.”
“Top Ten Reasons to Oppose the Senate Amnesty Bill”
1. Rewards Illegal Behavior with Clear Path to Citizenship and Voting Rights – Amnesty
2. Creates Temporary Worker Program That is Neither Temporary Nor Work-Based
3. Unprecedented Wave of Immigrants - 66 Million Over 20 Years
4. Insufficient Border Security
5. Terrorist Loophole Disarms Law Enforcement
6. Social Security Benefits, Tax Credits for Illegal Work
7. Costs Over $50 Billion A Year to Federal Government; States Foot The Bill for Immigrant Health Care
8. Hurts Small Business
9. Gives Some Immigrant Workers Greater Job Protection Than American Workers
10. Weak Assimilation/English Requirements
http://demint.senate.gov/index.cfm?FuseAction=PressReleases.Detail&PressRelease_id=380 - 5/26/06, 9:04 AM
-
-
Like I stated, if we aren't going to enforce the laws, WTF?
7. Employers get a tax pardon for hiring illegal aliens -- Under the bill, employers of aliens applying for adjustment of status “shall not be subject to civil and criminal tax liability relating directly to the employment of such alien.” Businesses that hired illegal workers would now get off scott-free from paying the taxes that they owe the government. This encourages employers to violate our tax laws and not pay what they owe the federal government. In addition to not having to pay their taxes, employers are also off the hook for providing illegal aliens with records or evidence that they have worked in the U.S. The employer is not subject to civil and criminal liability for having employed illegal aliens in the past, or before enactment.
http://grassley.senate.gov/index.cfm?FuseAction=PressReleases.View&PressRelease_id=5073
Juice - 5/26/06, 12:08 PM
- curmudgeon said...
-
It's only a start, but they rounded up 170 here in the L.V. valley over the last week and mailed them back home. WOOHOO!!!
- 5/26/06, 3:17 PM
-
-
-- Illegal aliens can *choose* which of the 5 years to pay taxes on -- and verification/burden of proof is up to the IRS.
-- Illegals who have committed "hate crimes" [yeahyeahyeah - I know; but anyway] cannot stay. Illegals here for over 5 years who have committed "hate crimes" can stay.
-- Capitalist Pigs who hire illegals can - while their citizenship amnesty is awaiting ajudication - neglect to pay into the Social Security fund for 'em. Yet whenever the illegals want it, they can claim SS based on that very same employment period.
-- I'm not sure about this one, but I think they can also steal a citizen's car and get amnesty, too -- so long at that citizen is a registered Republican.
-- And I think calling an illegal "you a-hole" in espanish will become a felony.
[NB the first three **are** legit. sad situation I hadda provide that caveat...] - 5/27/06, 2:15 PM
-
-
Goody, fencing and barriers. But wait...other language requires consultation and coordination with the Mexican government? Gee, how many years will that stall the new fencing? Ten? Twenty?
So basically, there *is* fencing in the Senate version, just *no* realistic chance of it ever being built.
Indications are that much of the Senate bill has add-ons and oh-by-the-ways for most of the major enforcement measures, and large exceptions for any restrictions on benefits or eligibility. There's not much besides large-scale handouts and give-aways in the Senate bill.
From what I hear, the Senate has essentially singled out the illegals for special treatment that regular folks (you and me!) aren't entitled to. My question is:
Does something this egregious violate the "equal protection" clause of the Constitution? - 5/27/06, 11:22 PM
- Rodger the Real King of France said...
-
In the meanwhile our real law enforcement agency on the border have started building that fence without consulting nary a perpetrator! Hoooo-ah!
- 5/28/06, 6:26 AM