Sunday, December 30, 2007

RIAA

Download Uproar: Record Industry Goes After Personal Use





In legal documents in its federal case against Jeffrey Howell, a Scottsdale, Ariz., man who kept a collection of about 2,000 music recordings on his personal computer, the industry maintains that it is illegal for someone who has legally purchased a CD to transfer that music into his computer.

This blog has a full legion of supporters of digital copyright law, and I am nominally one of them.  However, with each story like this I'm growing more militant over  the heavy handed greed these MoFos  exhibit.

I've recently been transferring my home video - HOME VIDEO -  from VHS to DVD, and the gyrations I have to go through are enough to make me scream.  For instance, if I want to edit one of these DVDs after the fact, I have to copy the entire disk back to my hard drive because SHOWBIZ, the software I used to burn the DVD in the first place, is prohibited from downloading the content directly from disk.  Someone at a Christmas party requested a copy of a community video I'd made, and recently transferred.  "Sure, in fact I'll do it right now.  Just take about 15 mins."  Nuh-uh.  After four long copy processes aborted at the every end of the 30 minute copy process, I gave up.  I know damn well, from past experience, that I'd run afoul of some anti-piracy thingy in the copy program.  Don't talk about Apple, either.  Try copying  your iPod music to disk (no, I am not interested in learning how).  And what about these guys?  Are you kidding me? How about we go back to sending them to prison?

One solution is to poke back.  If every person in the freaking world downloaded  peer to peer software, and spent a day downloading every song and movie they could get their hands on, it would drive these bastard's compliance and legal fees through the roof.  Oh, one more thing is necessary.  Each participant who is actually sued by these pricks has to show up in court strapped to the gills with C-4, and blow themselves up whilst standing next to plaintiff's attorneys.  In fact, that's prolly a good idea in any tort case.  Yes, you'll be dead, but so to is patriot Nathan Hale, and he has schools named after him.

Thanks to MoFiZiX Gr4FiX for turning me to early whiskey.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Lotsa stuff dealing with lawyers today. Its sad really, that 99% of lawyers give the rest a bad name.
Tim

MoFiZiX Gr4FiX said...

Mamma made me wait until we got back from Mass and it was after 12:00EST, but right after lunch I took out my bottle of Scotch that I got from a friend this Christmas and as we speak, I'm drinking to your health and sanity. Auf Dich Mein Lieber Schlong!

Anonymous said...

Only two groups of people support our current version of copyright law; the cabal of lawyers and industry thugs who pocket fortunes by controlling distribution; and those who are ignorant of the changes to copyright in the past decade. Public Domain is an engine of creativity in a free market. When software became a public commodity, the law should have recognized the short shelf life of created work, and reduced copyright protection to a shorter period of time so that the previous works of others were not lost to the ages. Instead our politicians rolled over for the organized crime thugs of the recording industry and made copyright infringement a criminal offense, and extended copyrights so that nothing created in your lifetime will move into the public domain while you're still alive. Music is a pimple on the ass of this issue. They have fucked the consumer and the US economy, but not to worry, one may find what one needs offshore.

Casca

Anonymous said...

That's ridiculous and also the line I'll cross. And have repeatedly. My iTunes is full of my personal CDs.
MM

Anonymous said...

You're absolutely right, Casca. There are two types of people who support current copyright law; the parasites who make all the money and people who don't know much about the issue. Copying your legally purchased cds onto your computer should be covered under Fair Use like taping vinyl records used to be. Now you're guilty of piracy until proven innocent if you have music on a computer that can access the internet.

Rodger, you think you have trouble with copyright protections when making copies of your own home-made dvds, just try selling them online. They all automatically assume that you are a bootlegger and act accordingly. You'll be lucky if all they do is get your host to cancel your account.

MM, they are talking about music "purchased" from the iTunes Store, not the iTunes music/video player program. Music "purchased" from iTunes is not in mp3 format and will only play on the computer that downloaded it and iPods which are keyed to that computer. iTunes music transferred using a flash drive or burned to a disk still won't play on other computers, so really, you're just renting it. If you replace your computer, you have to "buy" your music all over again.

The record companies keep talking about how much file sharing is hurting them and if it's allowed to continue that they might go under. They talk about this as if it's a bad thing and I guess it would be for them but not for anyone else. Does anyone believe that people will stop producing or listening to music without the record companies? If anything it would become more plentiful and cheaper without all those leaches. What does the record companies do for musicians? They produce, distribute and promote their music, but musicians can do all that for themselves these days. Maybe not as effectively as the industry can but for all but the biggest mega-groups most musicians can make more online since they get to keep all of the proceeds instead of giving the lion's share to a load of useless a-holes.

It's not the same with Hollywood. The studios have a wide range of creative, productive people and aren't made up of just parasites the way the music companies are. Plus they don't gouge their customers or prosecute them as badly.
GrinfilledCelt

Anonymous said...

Thank you Grin for that explanation
MM

Anonymous said...

"Say cheese"

Post a Comment

Just type your name and post as anonymous if you don't have a Blogger profile.